By the numbers
- €20 millionor 4% of worldwide annual turnover, whichever is higher: the GDPR's top fine, which covers the conditions for consentGDPR Article 83(5)
- €325 millionfine for Google from France's CNIL in September 2025, partly for ads shown between Gmail users' emails without consentCNIL, September 3, 2025
- 78%of EU internet users bought something online in 2025, up from 62% in 2015Eurostat, e-commerce statistics for individuals
- 21%of Shopify's 2025 revenue came from merchants in Europe, the Middle East and AfricaShopify 2025 annual report (Form 10-K)
Figures are from the law itself, regulators and official statistics. Shopify reports revenue by merchant region, not a count of European merchants.
Do you need consent for a popup signup?
In the EU, yes. The ePrivacy Directive allows marketing email only to people who have given prior consent (Article 13(1)), and the UK's PECR regulation 22 says the same. The one exception, the soft opt-in, covers contact details collected during a sale, for marketing your own similar products, with an easy way to refuse. Someone typing an email into a welcome popup has usually not bought anything yet, so the soft opt-in doesn't cover them. In the US, CAN-SPAM works the other way round: no prior consent is needed, but you must honor unsubscribes within 10 business days, and each non-compliant email can cost up to $53,088.
What valid consent looks like
The GDPR defines consent as "freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous", given by "a statement or by a clear affirmative action" (Article 4(11)). Recital 32 adds that "silence, pre-ticked boxes or inactivity" do not count. On a popup that means three things. Say what they are signing up for, in words: emails about new products and offers from your brand. Make them do something to agree: type an address and press a button, or tick a box. And never pre-tick anything. The fine for getting the conditions of consent wrong sits in the GDPR's top tier: up to €20 million or 4% of worldwide turnover.
Is a checkbox required?
The GDPR asks for a clear affirmative act, not a checkbox. A button that says "Sign me up" under wording that explains the emails is an act many stores rely on. A separate box helps when the form does more than one thing, such as entering a giveaway, unlocking a discount or collecting a phone number, so the marketing choice can't be mistaken for the other one. The EU's top court made the same point about cookies in Planet49 in 2019: pressing a button to join a promotional lottery was not consent to cookies, and a pre-ticked box was not consent at all. Veya shows your consent wording as a notice under the button by default, and lets you switch on a required checkbox that starts unchecked.
Can you offer a discount for an email?
Incentives are not banned. The European Data Protection Board's consent guidelines say the GDPR "does not preclude all incentives", but the business must be able to show consent was still freely given. Article 7(4) asks whether something was made conditional on consent it doesn't need. In practice: describe the trade honestly ("Get 10% off your first order and our emails"), let people unsubscribe at any time without losing anything they already have, and don't make the discount the only way to buy at a fair price. Have your lawyer review the wording if you sell mostly into the EU.
Double opt-in
Double opt-in sends a confirmation email and adds the address only after the person clicks. The GDPR doesn't require it, but it proves the address belongs to the person who typed it, which a form alone can't, and in Germany it is the expected practice for marketing email. Klaviyo makes double opt-in the default for new lists, and a double opt-in signup through its API doesn't create a profile until the subscriber confirms. Veya sends each signup to the Klaviyo list you choose, and that list's own single or double opt-in setting applies.
Keep proof of consent
Article 7(1) puts the burden on you: "the controller shall be able to demonstrate" that the person consented. Keep, for each signup, the exact wording they saw, when they agreed, where, and on what device. Veya refuses an email signup that doesn't carry consent, and stores the consent text as published, the time, the IP address, the browser and the page (without its query string) with every signup. You can download it as a CSV, and every webhook carries it. Klaviyo receives the subscription with its consent status, and Klaviyo itself warns that its consent property alone shouldn't be your proof, so keep the Veya record.
Make it as easy to leave
"It shall be as easy to withdraw as to give consent" (Article 7(3)). For email, that is an unsubscribe link in every message, which Klaviyo adds, and no hoops after it: no login, no survey before it takes effect. Tell people on the popup that they can unsubscribe at any time. Veya's default consent wording says exactly that: "I agree to receive marketing emails. I can unsubscribe at any time."
Texts need their own consent
SMS marketing needs its own yes, separate from email. Veya asks for text consent with its own wording whenever a form collects a phone number, as a separate unchecked box or a notice, and its server never treats email consent as consent to texts. Klaviyo receives each channel's subscription on its own, only when that channel was agreed to.
Where the data goes, and how to delete it
Under the GDPR the store is the controller and the popup tool a processor, so you need a data processing agreement with it. Veya is hosted in AWS us-west-2 (Oregon), relies on Standard Contractual Clauses for transfers from the EU, and provides a DPA on request. On Shopify, Veya handles the privacy webhooks: a customer data request returns an export, and a redact request deletes that shopper's signups, consent records and events. Data already delivered to Klaviyo stays in Klaviyo, so delete it there as well.
Fines are real
Regulators fine marketing without consent. France's CNIL fined Google €325 million in September 2025, partly for showing ads between Gmail users' emails without their consent, and fined Orange €50 million in November 2024 for the same practice. Those are giants, but the rules are the same for a store with one popup, and EU shoppers are worth the care: Eurostat found 78% of EU internet users bought online in 2025.
Questions
Is an email popup GDPR compliant?
It can be. Say clearly what people are signing up for, ask for an action such as pressing a sign-up button or ticking an unticked box, never pre-tick anything, let people unsubscribe easily, and keep a record of each consent.
Do I need a checkbox on my newsletter popup?
Not always. The GDPR requires a clear affirmative act, and a sign-up button under clear wording is one many stores use. Add a separate unticked box when the form does something else too, such as entering a giveaway or giving a discount, so the marketing choice is unambiguous.
Can I give a discount in exchange for an email under GDPR?
Incentives are not banned: the EDPB says the GDPR does not preclude all incentives, but you must be able to show consent was freely given. Describe the trade honestly and let people unsubscribe without losing anything they already have.
Is double opt-in required by GDPR?
No. The GDPR doesn't mention it, but double opt-in proves the address belongs to the person who signed up, and it is the expected practice in Germany. Klaviyo makes it the default for new lists.
What counts as proof of consent?
A record of who agreed, when, how and to what: the email address, the timestamp, the exact consent wording shown, the page and the device or IP address. Keep it for as long as you email the person.
Does GDPR apply to a US store?
It applies when you offer goods to people in the EU, wherever your business is. The UK has its own GDPR and PECR with the same consent rules for marketing email.
Sources
- GDPR Article 4, definitions
- GDPR Article 7, conditions for consent
- GDPR Recital 32, conditions for consent
- GDPR Article 83, administrative fines
- ePrivacy Directive 2002/58/EC, Article 13
- UK PECR, regulation 22
- EDPB Guidelines 05/2020 on consent (version 1.1)
- Court of Justice of the EU, Planet49 (C-673/17), press release, October 1, 2019
- Klaviyo help center, how to collect GDPR-compliant consent
- Klaviyo help center, understanding the double opt-in process
- FTC, CAN-SPAM Act compliance guide for business
- CNIL, Google fined €325 million (September 3, 2025)
- CNIL, Orange fined €50 million (December 10, 2024)
- Eurostat, e-commerce statistics for individuals (2025)
- Shopify Inc., Form 10-K for 2025
- Veya privacy policy
Figures checked November 12, 2026.