By the numbers
- 7 of 54phone popups in our Shopify census were partly or fully covered by the store's own cookie bannerVeya popup census, November 2, 2026
- 29.1%of visitors to fashion and jewelry sites in Europe never answered the consent banner in 2025Didomi, consent rate by industry 2026
- 11.8%of consent banners on 680 popular UK sites met minimal requirements based on European lawNouwens et al., Dark Patterns after the GDPR (CHI 2020)
- €150 millionfine for Shein from France's CNIL in September 2025 for placing cookies without consentCNIL, September 2025
The census is our own: 81 Shopify stores loaded on a phone and a laptop on November 2, 2026. Didomi's figures come from sites using its consent platform.
What we saw on real stores
Before Black Friday we loaded 81 well-known Shopify stores on a phone. 54 showed a popup there, and on 7 of them (13%) the store's own cookie banner covered the email field, the submit button or the whole popup. At Olipop it was the submit button. Nobody at those brands chose that outcome: two tools were each told to appear early, at the bottom of the screen or above everything else, and neither knew about the other. The fix is to decide the order on purpose.
Banner first, popup second
The cookie banner should win. It is often a legal requirement in the EU and the UK, Google's interstitial guidance exempts interstitials that answer a legal obligation, and an unanswered banner leaves your analytics and ad tags waiting. An email popup is optional. So give the banner the first seconds, and show the popup after the visitor has answered it or after a delay long enough to answer it. In our census the median popup appeared after about 7 seconds, and a third appeared within 5.
Don't wait forever
Many visitors never answer a consent banner. Didomi's 2026 benchmark found 29.1% of visitors to European fashion and jewelry sites made no choice, and between 21.7% and 27.4% by region across all industries. A popup that waits for an answer would never reach those shoppers. Wait for an answer or a delay, whichever comes first, and keep the two out of each other's way on screen, so a banner left open doesn't hide the signup button.
Keep them apart on the screen
Most banners dock to the bottom of a phone screen, which is exactly where a popup's button and a flyout sit. Check three things. The popup's submit button must stay visible and tappable with the banner open. The banner's Accept and Reject buttons must stay reachable with the popup open. And neither should win simply by having the higher z-index. Veya draws its popup above everything else on the page, so it will sit over a banner: give the banner time first with a delay, and check both on a phone before you publish.
What a popup may store before consent
The ePrivacy rule on storing information on a visitor's device (Article 5(3)) covers more than cookies. The European Data Protection Board's 2024 guidelines name local storage alongside cookies, so a popup's "seen" and "signed up" flags fall under the same rule. France's CNIL lists trackers that store the user's own choice as exempt from consent; whether a popup's dismissed flag qualifies is a question for your lawyer. The careful default is to store nothing before consent and accept that the popup may repeat.
How Shopify's Customer Privacy API settles it
On Shopify, the store's consent settings are readable from any script through window.Shopify.customerPrivacy, which answers whether analytics, marketing and preferences processing are allowed, and fires a visitorConsentCollected event when the visitor chooses. Where a region needs consent, those purposes are off until the visitor says yes. Shopify's own banner switches on automatically for the UK and EEA when a store has markets there. A third-party banner must use the same regions and pass its answer to Shopify, or apps reading the API see no choice at all.
How Veya behaves on Shopify
Veya reads the Customer Privacy API before it stores anything and acts again the moment the visitor chooses. It sets no cookies. Its visitor id and frequency cap live in local storage only with preferences consent; its session and page context live in session storage only with analytics consent, and without it Veya sends no events, visits or A/B assignments. Looking a visitor up in Klaviyo needs marketing consent. The popup itself can still appear before consent, and a signup still reaches your list, because the signup is the visitor's own consent to emails, sent with its consent record but without the visitor id or browsing context.
Off Shopify
On WooCommerce, Webflow or a custom site, Veya can't read your cookie banner, so it treats every purpose as allowed. If your visitors need to consent first, have your consent platform load the Veya script only after the visitor accepts the relevant category. Most consent tools can hold a script until then; set it up once and test it in a fresh private window.
Reject must be as easy as accept
Regulators look hard at banners that make refusing harder than agreeing. The UK's ICO told the country's top sites in November 2023 to make "Reject All" as easy as "Accept All", and reported in January 2024 that 38 of the 53 it wrote to had changed their banners. The same idea applies to the popup: don't make accepting cookies a condition of the discount, and don't style the popup so it can be mistaken for the consent banner. In Planet49 (2019) the EU's top court held that pressing a button to enter a promotional lottery was not consent to cookies.
Test the pair together
Open your store in a private window on a phone, from an EU or UK location if you sell there, so both the banner and the popup appear as a new visitor would see them. Check that you can answer the banner, then sign up, then do it the other way round: ignore the banner and try to reach the popup's button. Repeat at 320 pixels wide, the narrowest common phone, where overlaps are worst.
Questions
Should the cookie banner or the email popup come first?
The cookie banner. It is often a legal requirement and the popup is optional. Show the popup after the visitor answers the banner or after a short delay, and make sure neither covers the other's buttons on a phone.
Why is my cookie banner covering my popup?
Both are set to appear early and both sit at the bottom or top layer of the screen. Delay the popup, move one of them, or lower whichever does not need to be on top, then test on a phone.
Can a popup show before cookie consent?
A popup can appear, but under the ePrivacy rules it shouldn't store or read anything on the visitor's device, including local storage, unless that is strictly necessary or the visitor consented. A signup is the visitor's own consent to emails, which is a separate question from cookies.
Does local storage need cookie consent?
The EDPB's guidelines on Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy Directive name local storage alongside cookies, so the same consent rule applies to it, with the same exemption for storage that is strictly necessary for a service the user asked for.
How does a popup read Shopify cookie consent?
Through Shopify's Customer Privacy API: window.Shopify.customerPrivacy reports whether analytics, marketing and preferences processing are allowed, and the visitorConsentCollected event fires when the visitor chooses.
Do I need a cookie banner if Shopify has one?
Shopify's banner covers Shopify's own tools and apps that read its consent settings. Shopify says third-party cookies or pixels installed by hand or through apps may need their own banner or custom logic.
Sources
- Veya popup census, November 2, 2026 (CSV)
- Didomi, average consent rate by industry in Europe (2026)
- Didomi, average consent rate by region in Europe (2026)
- Nouwens, Liccardi, Veale, Karger and Kagal, Dark Patterns after the GDPR (CHI 2020)
- EDPB Guidelines 2/2023 on the technical scope of Article 5(3) of the ePrivacy Directive
- CNIL guidelines on cookies and other trackers
- CNIL, Shein fined €150 million (September 2025)
- ICO, warning to make advertising cookies compliant (January 31, 2024)
- ICO, Commissioner warns UK's top websites to make cookie changes (November 21, 2023)
- Shopify, Customer Privacy API
- Shopify help center, customer privacy settings
- Google Search Central blog, helping users easily access content on mobile (2016)
- Court of Justice of the EU, Planet49 (C-673/17), press release, October 1, 2019
Figures checked November 12, 2026.