We opened 81 Shopify stores. Here’s what the popups asked for.

On November 2, 2026, 25 days before Black Friday, we loaded 81 well-known Shopify stores as a first-time visitor on a phone and a laptop, and looked at every screenshot. More than a third of the phone popups didn’t ask for an email on the first screen. One in eight had its form hidden by the store’s own cookie banner. Only one mentioned Black Friday.

By the numbers

Counts from one visit per device on November 2, 2026, to a hand-picked list of stores. They describe what stores show, not what converts.

What the first screen looks like

  • Brooklinen phone popup asking “Hi, want 15% off?” with a Yes button and no form fieldBrooklinen. One button, no field.
  • Kosas full-screen popup headed “Reveal Your Reward” with a paint stroke to swipeKosas. Swipe a paint stroke to reveal the offer.
  • Summersalt popup headed “Try your luck” with four face-down cardsSummersalt. Match two cards.
  • ColourPop spin-to-win wheel offering up to 15% offColourPop. A wheel on this visit, a scratch card on another.
  • Olipop popup with the email field visible and the submit button covered by a cookie bannerOlipop. The cookie banner covers the submit button.
  • Tatcha popup headed “Unlock Our Black Friday Preview” with email and birthday fieldsTatcha. The only popup that named Black Friday.

More than a third don’t ask for an email first

Of the 54 stores with a popup on the phone, 34 put an email or phone field on the first screen. The other 20 (37%) asked for something smaller: 8 asked a question, 6 showed a button and 6 opened with a game. Brooklinen says “Hi, want 15% off?” over a single Yes button. Milk Bar asks who you’re shopping for. Fly By Jing asks how spicy you like it, and ThirdLove asks for your band and cup size. The email comes on a later screen. This runs ahead of wider samples: Recart counted 21% of popups with no input across the top 10,000 Shopify stores, and Wisepops found 48% of 500 mid-sized stores running a multi-step popup. Our list leans toward big brands, so expect a smaller share at smaller stores. We didn’t measure signups, so this shows what stores do, not what works.

Games are more common here than anyone reports

6 of 54 phone popups (11%) were games: spin wheels at ColourPop, Fashion Nova and Native, a scratch card at Knix, a swipe-to-reveal at Kosas and a card match at Summersalt. Recart reports 0.2% for gamified offers across its 10,000 stores. We can’t fully explain a gap that wide. Our list is smaller and better known, and the two counts may define a game differently. They also change between visits. ColourPop showed a wheel on one phone visit and a scratch card on another, and Beekman 1802 and Summersalt each showed something different on a second look, which suggests these stores are testing them against other formats.

One in eight loses to the cookie banner

On 7 of 54 phone popups (13%), the store’s own cookie banner covered the part you need. At Chubbies, Olipop, Girlfriend Collective, Great Jones and TomboyX it hid the field or the button. At Pangaia and Stumptown the whole popup sat behind it. A shopper can clear the banner and carry on, but the first thing they see is two requests stacked on each other, and the offer is partly out of sight. Consent tools and popups are usually set up separately, so nobody is looking at them together. The check takes a minute: open your store in a private window on a real phone and look at what appears, in what order.

10% is still the most common offer

29 of 54 phone popups stated a flat percentage: 10% at 11 stores, 15% at 9, 20% at 7, with one each at 5% and 25%. Wisepops also found 10% the most common first-order discount. Four offered dollars off, including $20 at Chubbies, Milk Bar and ThirdLove. Four offered free shipping, and three a gift or service, such as Nomad’s $35 gift and Casper’s mattress removal. Seven kept the offer hidden until a later step, three offered no incentive at all (Harry’s, Skims and Tatcha), and HexClad ran a sweepstakes for a trip worth over $150,000.

Most arrive within ten seconds

We could time 51 of the phone popups. The median appeared at about 7 seconds, 33% within 5 seconds, 69% within 10, and 20% after 15. Treat these as rough: they include page load on a busy test machine, and a real shopper’s connection will differ.

Black Friday hasn’t reached the popup yet

Only Tatcha’s popup named it, with “Unlock Our Black Friday Preview”. Olipop’s ran a holiday message and Magic Spoon’s a November 2 to 8 offer. The stores themselves were further along: Caraway’s homepage already said “Black Friday Came Early”, and Owala ran a countdown bar. So on November 2 the sale was on the page, while the popup was still running its everyday offer. We plan to repeat this scan through Cyber Monday and record what changes.

How we measured, and what to be careful about

We started from 120 well-known direct-to-consumer brands we picked ourselves, so this is not a random sample and it leans toward large US brands. We dropped 18 whose robots.txt disallowed the visit or gave no clear answer, and one duplicate brand, keeping 101. 82 of those were Shopify stores that loaded, and one had no usable screenshot, leaving 81. Each store got one visit per device in a fresh browser with no cookies, from a US connection, at 390 by 844 and 1440 by 900 pixels. We waited about 20 seconds, scrolled halfway, and on desktop moved the mouse toward the top of the window. We submitted nothing and identified the scanner in its user agent. An AI model reviewed each screenshot and coded it, using the page text where a banner hid the form. We only saw the first screen, popups rotate, and some stores will show other visitors something else. Veya sells signup popups, so weigh that too. The row-by-row data is linked below.

Sources

Figures checked November 2, 2026.

Your next popup?
We’ll build it for you.

14-day free trial on every plan. Custom design and revisions included.